Her words were unequivocal
Dana’s messages do not show a brief or distant encounter. They show years of repeated engagement with Liana’s programs, prayers, meditations, health guidance, public posts, and Illuminations.
Across that record, Dana described Liana’s work as empowering, life-altering, soothing, spiritually important, and invaluable.
“As you know, I have ENDLESS gratitude for you, your gifts, and your teachings.”Dana Chalamet
“I ABSOLUTELY LOVE Illuminations”
Dana repeatedly wrote after listening—often saying she planned to listen again.
Dana’s words
“I am beyond grateful, Liana. Beyond grateful! THANK you from the bottom of my heart!”
Dana’s words
“BAFFLING to see people choose darkness. But grateful to not be them.”
Dana’s words
“Just when I can’t imagine Illuminations and your prayers/clearings being any more awesome, Liana, you surpass the last.”
Dana’s words
“I didn’t listen to those whispers and so I WAS ‘pushed’ and we know what that means.”
Dana’s words
“I allowed the energy/spirit of anger in…by NOT mastering my own energy.”
Dana’s words
“Thank God that in the midst of my stubbornness and my ego getting in the way…”
Dana’s words
“I can’t even TELL you how much I ABSOLUTELY LOVE Illuminations!”
Dana’s words
“This clearing was absolutely invaluable. Thank you a billion times over.”
Dana’s words
“Every coffee break starts with your prayer and the Crystalline Heart Meditation.”
Dana’s words
“Illuminations was jam packed. I feel safe in the hands of Jesus.”
Dana’s words
“It’s your medicine.”
Dana’s words
“MASTERCLASS. I cannot wait to listen again.”
Dana’s words
“Thank you for being our teacher. Always grateful.”
Dana’s words
“Illuminations for this week…jam PACKED. Wow! Always, ALWAYS, so grateful!”
Dana’s words
“I could NEVER imagine our lives without your teachings, insight, and guidance.”
Dana’s words
“A whole new level of pure gratitude for your gift, teachings, and wisdom.”
Dana’s words
“We are deeply grateful that we were led to you years ago.”
Dana’s words
“So incredibly grateful you are in our lives to guide us.”
Dana’s words
“There truly are no words for the person you are to SO many!”
Support when Liana was under attack
Before the relationship ended, Dana rejected efforts to discredit Liana and praised her for speaking what Dana called truth.
Dana’s words
“So grateful for your gifts and for ALWAYS speaking/teaching TRUTH!”
Dana’s words
“THANK YOU! Always SO grateful! ALWAYS!”
Dana’s words
“Sick, pathetic, sad, tragic, deluded, dark lost soul.”
Dana’s words
“It’s MIND BOGGLING that SO many just turned over so quickly and didn’t use critical thinking/common sense.”
Dana’s words
“Ha. Stace shared this with me. Right on! So true.”
Dana’s words
“It doesn’t matter how hard they try to ‘discredit’ you. Nope. Won’t work.”
Dana’s words
“Ahhh. I just saw that you shared it. Awesome!”
Dana’s words
“You stand firm. We should all aspire to do the same.”
Programs, health, prayer, and everyday guidance
These messages show the breadth and frequency of Dana’s engagement across Liana’s work.
Dana’s words
“We haven’t been sick, been to a doctor in decades and NO HARMaceuticals!”
Dana’s words
“I can’t even TELL you what an enormous difference all of it made for me.”
Dana’s words
“Which brand do you take for the L-Tyrosine?”
Dana’s words
“That whole message of ‘fear not’ was yet another thing speaking directly to me.”
Dana’s words
“So grateful for your teachings and guidance.”
Dana’s words
“You. Are. Gutsy! I hear you on NOT just standing by.”
Dana’s words
“Just so grateful for your gifts, guidance/teachings, love, for your existence.”
Dana’s words
“So THANK YOU once again, Liana! And as always, SOOOO much LOVE and GRATITUDE for you!!!”
Dana’s words
“Loved, loved, LOVED the first episode!”
Dana’s words
“No language can adequately express our gratitude for you.”
Dana’s words
“We are the master of our ‘Play-Doh’ (aka energy) was brilliant…and totally clicked for me!”
Dana’s words
“Another Illuminations peeled back more layers of programming.”
Dana’s words
“ENDLESS gratitude. You are the biggest Light I know.”
Dana’s words
“When I see her, my spirit feels the darkness.”
Dana’s words
“It’s obvious you sick evil F. Everyone sees who you are!”
Dana’s words
“This definitely started to uncover some things…that I was already suspicious of as being part of my physical issues.”
Dana’s words
“My spirit knows I am finally on the right path. Thank you.”
Dana’s words
“Thank you for the guidance on the cleanse programs and the holiday support.”
Dana’s words
“We both think you’re just incredible in SO many ways…gifted, brilliant, and super-powered beyond anyone we have ever know or will ever know.”
Liana’s words
“I thought you were joking. You hear something new every day lol.”
Dana’s words
“I assumed you’d understand what I meant by how I phrased it…that they ‘symbolized’ a dark nature.”
Dana’s words
“SO. Fucking. Ridiculous!!! And hilarious.”
Dana’s words
“Thank you for sharing the breakfast pudding.”
Dana’s words
“I can’t even TELL you how much I ABSOLUTELY LOVE Illuminations!”
The relationship included personal attention and practical help
Liana’s later account says she answered many of Dana’s questions personally without charging for her time. The surviving messages show that Dana and Stacey both had access to Liana’s community.
When Stacey was seeking professional work, Liana referred her to someone who needed creative and editing support. That referral appears in the Substack record but was not in Dana’s Dropbox folder.
“Thank you SO much for being so kind and generous to refer [her] to me.”Stacey Aaronson to Liana
Community record
“Dana Chalamet · Stacey Aaronson.”
Stacey’s words
“Thank you for being so kind and generous.”
She had already named anger, stubbornness, and resistance in her own life
In September 2023, Dana described an incident she connected to anger, ego, and not mastering her energy. In the same exchange, she wrote about a 38-year friendship she had known for a long time was no longer aligned—but continued holding onto because of their history.
This sequence is included as context for what Dana herself said before her later rupture with Liana. It does not require the broader psychological teaching from the Substack article to be understood.
“Thank God that in the midst of my stubbornness and my ego getting in the way…”Dana Chalamet
Dana’s words
“Illuminations (9/17) was SO SPOT ON for what I needed…INCLUDING the prayer/clearing!”
Dana’s words
“I allowed the energy/spirit of anger in…by NOT mastering my own energy.”
Dana’s words
“For a very long time now, I’ve known (or felt) it was no longer in alignment with me and who I am today.”
Dana’s words
“My stubbornness and my ego got in the way of what I knew.”
Dana’s words
“I knew it was FOR ME, as it covered SO much I needed to hear AND claim.”
Dana’s words
“I didn’t listen to those whispers and so I WAS ‘pushed.’”
Dana’s words
“Our history kept me holding on when I knew it was time to let go.”
Dana’s words
“I am BEYOND grateful, Liana. Beyond grateful!”
Dana asked Liana to change how she posted animal-cruelty content
Dana said images of animal suffering affected her profoundly and repeatedly asked Liana to provide warnings. At one point she wrote that she had been “subjected, without my permission” to the material.
Dana then retracted that phrase, acknowledged that it was Liana’s Instagram account, and apologized. Liana responded at length: she said she understood Dana’s reaction, explained why she would continue sharing the material, and said she understood if Dana chose to unfollow.
“I totally understand anyone who is not yet at that place…who needs to unfollow.”Liana Shanti’s response to Dana
Dana’s words
“It only took me seeing this for 2 seconds and I was RUINED.”
Dana’s words
“Nesting in these types of images within your other posts…without any warning, is extremely traumatic for me.”
Dana’s words
“I don’t need to be constantly reminded and assaulted by these images.”
Dana’s words
“I am simply highly sensitive to animals.”
Dana’s words
“I saw a baby deer beside its dead sibling.”
Dana’s words
“I was devastated, and equally devastating was the look on that fawn’s face.”
Dana’s words
“I’m sharing all of this to ask you one more time to please put a warning before any animal cruelty stories.”
Dana’s words
“If it’s all to ADD LIGHT, by us SEEING it, then why aren’t you also including children and women?”
Dana’s words
“I retract ‘without my permission.’ It is your account and you can post what you want. I apologize.”
Liana’s words
“Yes it would be true and I would show more shocking photos of human abuse but they would be removed by IG.”
Liana’s words
“I have such a profound reaction to animals being harmed or not cared for.”
Liana’s words
“I take 100% of my direction from Jesus and I have for 52 years.”
Liana’s words
“But I’m not here to be that person that follows trends and makes things more palatable.”
Liana’s words
“I intentionally follow a number of accounts who post almost all animal awareness/cruelty info.”
Liana’s words
“It would be disingenuous of me to teach unconditional love to my students, but then worry more about how sad and gutted I am.”
Liana’s words
“And to shield myself from it. Or shield anyone else. That’s not what Jesus teaches.”
“Just very sad as I’m feeling I lost a best friend.”
Illuminations had been offered for years at $20. When it moved into Liana’s new app and the price became $50, Dana asked why the original price had not continued indefinitely and said she did not value the added community features enough to justify the increase.
There was nothing unusual about declining a new price. The turning point in the exchange was relational: Dana described the loss of the former subscription as feeling like the loss of a best friend. Liana answered that Dana was not someone she wanted as a listener and then removed her from the community.
What the screenshot record establishes
Before the boundary: years of direct praise, gratitude, questions, program use, public defense, and repeated statements that Liana’s guidance was central to Dana’s life.
At the boundary: a dispute about a price change, Dana’s statement that she felt she had lost a best friend, Liana’s decision to end the customer relationship, and the administrative removal from Liana Life.
After the boundary: Liana later wrote that Dana aligned with people attacking her. That later conduct is identified here as Liana’s account; the displayed message record establishes the history leading up to the break and the break itself.
Dana’s words
“What happened to the original $20 Illuminations price?”
Dana’s words
“Just very sad as I’m feeling I lost a best friend.”
Liana’s words
“Anyone who does not see $50 in value in my work is not someone I want as a listener.”
Dana’s words
“You misunderstood. I was asking why the original price no longer remained.”
Dana’s words
“Questions should not be treated as disrespect. With love and respect as always.”
Community record
“Banned.”
From calling Liana’s attackers “evil” to joining them
Before the boundary, Dana’s language about people attacking Liana was unequivocal. She called them “sick,” “evil,” “pathetic,” “deluded,” and “lunatic.” She wrote that efforts to “discredit” Liana would not work and praised Liana for standing firm.
Liana’s later account says that after the pricing exchange and removal, Dana followed an account associated with the person Liana identifies as her abuser and began making hostile comments about Liana. The contrast is the point documented here: Dana’s own earlier messages show how fully she had defended Liana and condemned the same kind of attacks before their relationship ended.
“It doesn’t matter how hard they try to ‘discredit’ you. Nope. Won’t work.”Dana Chalamet, before the relationship ended
Defense in Dana’s own words
The screenshots above record Dana describing Liana’s critics as dark, sick, pathetic, deluded, and irrational—and insisting that attempts to discredit Liana would fail.
The later conduct Liana describes
Liana says Dana then followed an account associated with the accused abuser and made hostile comments about her. That claim is attributed to Liana here; it is not presented as a conclusion supplied by the earlier screenshots.
“You chose $30 instead of your supposedly best friend.”
Carla Romanato responded publicly to Dana’s statement that the Illuminations price change felt like “losing a best friend.” Her response is included as a community reaction—not as Liana’s words and not as independent evidence about Dana’s later conduct.
Carla’s words
“Lady, you chose 30 dollars instead of your supposedly best friend.”
Complete evidence set: This page includes all 82 files from Dana’s Dropbox folder—including the three screenshots omitted from the unfinished old page—plus the Stacey referral screenshot found in the Substack article and the community-response screenshot supplied for this page.